Overall, it is unclear whether the lack of consistency across articles reflects the fact that there is little consensus about which variables are potential confounders or the beliefs that the protective effect of alcohol consumption on the risk for cardiovascular disease is independent of how well studies control for confounding, 29, 31, 32. The role of randomization to address confounding variables in. Confounding in case control studies pubmed central pmc. Observational studies can not control for all the things that people do or happen to them, so there is possibility of uncontrolled confounding. Confounding and interaction biometry 755 spring 2009 confounding and interaction p. Pdf how to control confounding effects by statistical. The difference in power between matched and unmatched studies diminishes rapidly as the control to case ratio is increased. Something we try to overcome in observational studies by using matched pairs of casecontrol, but almost always still part of the argument. Restriction also limits the interpretation of the study. Randomization is a simple tool in experimental design that allows the confounding variables to have their effect across a sample. You will learn how to understand and differentiate commonly used terminologies in epidemiology, such as chance, bias and confounding, and suggest measures to mitigate them. Design and analysis of casecontrol studies uc davis health. More details in the confounding and bias in case control studies.
Infants usual sleeping environment in relation to their parents was classified as usual room sleeper shared room but not. Extensions to the more realistic case where a set of variables are candidates for adjustment are outlined in section 2. In this lesson, we will look at ecological and case control study designs. Confounding and bias in cohort studies chichuan emma wang, ph. Matching in case control studies matching addresses issues of. Comparison group is chosen to be similar to the case group with respect to one or more potential confounding variables. Myfilesarticlesconfoundimpact of a confounding variable. The weakness in the experimental design was that they failed to take into account confounding variables, and did not try to eliminate or control any other factors. Wholly or partially accounts for apparent effect of exposure on disease either direction.
Pdf confounding variables in epidemiologic studies. Confounding, effect modification, and stratification. We conduct a casecontrol study recruiting mothers of 200 cases of congenia and mothers of 400 control children. Among those not exposed to e let exposure to c increase the risk of disease by a factor rc. Confounding is an important source of bias in nonexperimental studies, arising when the effect of an exposure on the occurrence of an outcome is distorted by the effect of some other factor. This reduces potential for confounding by generating groups that are fairly comparable with respect to known and unknown confounding variables. Request pdf confounding in casecontrol studies last weeks question described a population based casecontrol study that investigated whether infants sleeping environment was a risk.
Effectively, whereas in a cohort study matching is done to make exposure groups comparable on the matching variable, in a casecontrol study. Methods to identify and address confounding are discussed, as well as their strengths and limitations. Confounding may lead to errors in the conclusion of a study, but, when confounding variables are known, the effect may be fixed. Confounding and bias in casecontrol studies, chinglan cheng. In total, 1122 survivors of suspected acute myocardial infarction at. Numbers of controls matched to each case may also vary within a study dependent on the available number of controls possessing the necessary matching criteria.
Both to control confounding and to detect interaction, the effect of matching may sometimes be to reduce the power of a study. Imagine that in this case, there is in fact no relationship between drinking and longevity. Situation in which c may confound the affect of the e to d. A confounding variable is a factor associated with both the exposure. This contrasts with case control studies as they assess only one outcome variable that is, whatever outcome the cases have entered the study with. How to control confounding effects by statistical analysis, 2012. Confounding and bias in casecontrol studies chinglan cheng, ph. A randomeffects model was used to draw metaestimates of the relationship between anaemia and adult depression.
A confounding factor is one that is related to both the exposure and the outcome. Assessment and control for confounding by indication in. If we conduct a casecontrol study, with no matching on the variable c. Confounding in epidemiological studies health knowledge. A problem in the design and analysis of a casecontrol study is the identification of confounding factors. Confounding and selection bias in case control studies. Table 1 example of confounding in a hypothetical cohort. Confounding variables a confounding variable is a variable that. Assistant professor institute of clinical pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences, national cheng kung university 30 th annual meeting of the international society for pharmacoepidemiology taipei, taiwan october 23, 2014 1.
This method actually requires the investigators to control confounding in both the design and analysis phases of the study, because the analysis of matched study groups differs from that of unmatched studies. Confounding should not be allowed to distort the estimation of effect. We conduct a case control study recruiting mothers of 200 cases of congenia and mothers of 400 control children. If the confounder that is used as a matching variable is strongly related to the risk factor causing the outcome, matching will lead to an underestimation of the effect of that risk factor. Matching cases and controls on these variables ensured they were equally distributed between groups. For the most part, attention is confined to a dichotomous exposure variable, and a single dichotomous covariate. A confounder is an extraneous variable whose presence affects the variables being studied so that the results do not reflect the actual relationship between the variables under study. Jan 01, 2012 matching is commonly used in case control studies for example, if age and sex are the matching variables, then a 45 year old male case is matched to a male control with same age. Sometimes control of confounding only possible by matchingi. Example of confounding in a hypothetical cohort study of ischemic. Still, the choice of matching variables needs careful attention because, as will be described later, errors are frequently made. Sep 22, 2010 last weeks question described a population based casecontrol study that investigated whether infants sleeping environment was a risk factor for sudden infant death syndrome.
Confounding is essentially an intrinsic limitation of observational studies e. Alarge number of different sources and possible mechanisms of. The stratification score for a case control study is the probability of disease modeled as a function of potential confounders. This paper will deal both with the issues of confounding and of control, as the definition of a confounding factor is far from universal and there exist. This paper considers quantitatively the extent to which the interaction or confounding effects of covariates may influence the design of case control studies with particular reference to sample size requirements and the role of matching. Analysis of casecontrol studies the odds ratio or is used in casecontrol studies to estimate the strength of the association between exposure and outcome.
Note that it is not possible to estimate the incidence of disease from a case control study unless the study is population based and all cases in a defined population are obtained. Matching in case control studies matching addresses. Introduction for simplicity we first consider measurement of the relationship between a disease 0 and an agent under study e in the presence of a single confounding variable z. Role of chance, bias and confounding in epidemiological studies. Assistant professor school of pharmacy, national taiwan university 30th annual meeting of the international society for. Confounding in case control studies can be controlled for during the design stage. Confounding variables and causation randomized experiments. Any risk factor for a disease is a potential confounder. Confounding a variable that a is causally related to the disease under study or is a proxy for an unknown or unmeasured cause and b is associated with the exposure under study kesley. But there may be other variables which bring about both heavy drinking and decreased. Matched case control studies control for confounding by introducing stratification in the design phase of a study. Thus, confounding is a major threat to the validity of inferences made about cause and effect internal validity. In particular, the stratification score is a retrospective balancing score defined below for a casecontrol study. In casecontrol studies, however, matching is frequently used.
Epi info user guide chapter 12 statcalc 124 stratified analysis of 2by2 tables if confounding is present, associations between disease and exposure can be missed or falsely detected. Controlling for confounding in casecontrol studies parodi s. For each case, a control matched for age and sex with no history of coronary heart disease was enrolled. This paper explains that to be a potential confounder, a variable needs to. However, these studies tend to enroll people from broader backgrounds, possibly strengthening the generalizabilty of their results.
This work is licensed under a creative commons attribution. Abstract in case control studies, the role of adjustments for bias, and in particular the role of matching, has been extensively debated. Confounding variables or confounders are often defined as the variables correlate positively or negatively with both the dependent variable and the independent variable. Positive confounding when the observed association is biased away from the null and negative confounding when the observed association is biased toward the null both occur. Certain issues will not be addressed, notably methods of controlling confounding, andthe statistical analysis ofcase control studies. In research that draws on a quantitative research design, especially experimental research designs also called intervention studies, we try and control these. Restriction by the indication for a drug can be used to address confounding byindication in observational studies of medication use. It is a variable that interferes with the results of the study.
In this case age the confounder is associated with. Dealing with confounding in the analysis iarc publications. If restriction is carried to extremes the study may have a limited number of eligible participants. Assume there is a rare congenital disease called congenia. The study was conducted with the aim to compare the performance on a battery of six. If a pairmatched design is used, then matching must be taken. Prediction studies interest centers on being able to accurately estimate or predict the response for a given combination of predictors focus is not much about which predictor variable allow to do this or what their coef. Confounding effect of a third variable that accounts for all or some of the association between exposure and. Matching in case control studies matching addresses issues. Assistant professor school of pharmacy, national taiwan university 30th annual meeting of the international society for pharmacoepidemiology. An approach for controlling confounding after the completion of a study during data analysis is stratification. Case control studies are therefore placed low in the hierarchy of evidence. In total, 1122 survivors of suspected acute myocardial infarction at age 3049 years were recruited. In a hypothetical casecontrol study to examine the rela.
Any variable that you are not intentionally studying in your dissertation is an extraneous variable that could threaten the internal validity of your results see the article. A case control study examined the association between chronic helicobacter pylori infection and coronary heart disease at young ages. A casecontrol study examined the association between chronic helicobacter pylori infection and coronary heart disease at young ages. To summarize, confounding reflects the causal association between variables in the population under study, and will manifest itself similarly in both cohort and. What can go wrong sampled from the target population. Role of chance, bias and confounding in epidemiological. For example, cohort studies of smokers can simultaneously look at deaths from lung,cardiovascular, and cerebrovascular disease.
Age, locality, and time of sleep were potential confounders. Both confounding and interaction can be assessed by stratification on these other factors i. The authors show that the stratification score is a retrospective balancing score and thus plays a similar role in case control studies as the propensity score plays in prospective studies. A confounding variable gives rise to situations in which the effects of two processes are not separated, or the contribution of causal factors cannot be separated, or the measure of the effect of exposure or risk is distorted because of its association with other factors influencing the outcome of the study. Results a total of 9706 papers were retrieved, and 14 observational epidemiological studies 9 case control studies and 5 prospective cohort studies comprising 10 764 cases of depression were finally included in this metaanalysis. The implications of interaction effects for sample size requirements are more important. How to control confounding effects by statistical analysis. Observer or subject bias as a confounding variable. For epidemiologic matched case control study designs, sas programs were developed to match cases persons with diseaseevent of interest to controls comparison group of persons without diseaseevent of interest. In case control studies, matched variables most often are the age and sex. Therefore, an appreciation of potential sources of bias has becomea critical issue in epidemiology. This article discusses the importance, definition, and types of confounders in epidemiology.
Experimental studies next topic uses randomization as a tool to fight the occurrence of confounding. The interpretation of study findings or surveys is subject to debate, due to the possible errors in measurement which might influence the results. A situation in which the effect or association between an exposure and outcome is distorted by the presence of another variable. Sometimes theres a lot of variation in confounding variables that you cant control. The article also describes the difference among confounders, mediators, and effect modifiers. Confounding and control of confounding in nonexperimental. Instead odds ratio are the measure of association used when outcome is uncommon, e. Dealing with confounding in drug studies loreto carmona. The table below shows the results for this casecontrol study. But all these methods mentioned above are applicable at the time of study design and before the process of data gathering. Confounding variable an overview sciencedirect topics. However, the absence of a formal statement of the problem has led to disagreements, confusion, and occasionally to erroneous conclu sions. Matching, an appealing method to avoid confounding. Therefore, in case control studies, matching for confounding may result in overadjustment and even introduce confounding.
In all these cases, the recommended remedy is to control for the confounding factor, e. Control of confounding in study design restriction one of the conditions necessary for confounding to occur is that the confounding factor must be distributed unequally among the groups being compared. Briefly, a commonly used procedure for making statistical adjustments for confounding variables in case control and crosssectional studies when a disease is either present or absent e. Like restriction, this approach is straightforward, and it can be effective. In nonexperimental studies of patients with ckd or who are on chronic dialysis, confounding is a significant concern owing to the high burden of comorbid disease, extent of required clinical management. Linear regression, adjusted for confounding variables, was used to.
Confounding occurs when a confounding variable, c, is associated with the exposure, e, and also influences the disease outcome, d. For a given disease, a casecontrol study can investigate multiple exposures. For example, if somebody wanted to study the cause of myocardial infarct and thinks that the age is a probable confounding variable, each 67yearold infarct patient will be matched with a healthy 67yearold control person. Evaluation of confounding in epidemiologic studies. Note that it is not possible to estimate the incidence of disease from a casecontrol study unless the study is population based and all cases in a defined population are obtained. Observational studies are particularly susceptible to the effects of chance, bias and confounding, and these need to be considered at both the design and analysis stage of an epidemiological study so that their effects can be minimized.
Matching may be done on an individual basis pairmatching or on a group basis frequency matching. Unlike cohort studies, casecontrol studies cannot calculate incidence rates, relative risks or attributable risks. Confounding variables change with the independent variable as. Matched casecontrol studies control for confounding by introducing stratification in the design phase of a study. Restriction can be a powerful method to address a limited. A multiple logistic regression model for screening diabetes tabaei and herman. Matching in case control studies matching addresses issues of confounding in the design stage of a study as opposed to the analysis phase a means of providing a more. A confounding variable gives rise to situations in which the effects of two. In many studies, the possible bias of the researchers is one of the most important confounding variables.
A confounding factor is one that is associated with the disease and the exposure, but may not be of interest or observed. A potential confounding variable not measured in the study is called a lurking variable. Finding a statistically significant result is almost always more interesting than not finding a difference, so you need to constantly be on guard to control the effects of this bias. One of the most significant triumphs of the case control study was the demonstration of the link between tobacco smoking and lung cancer, by richard doll and bradford hill. How to control confounding effects by statistical analysis article pdf available in gastroenterology and hepatology from bed to bench 52. Thus, conditional on the stratification score and absent residual confounding, the distributions of exposures among case and control participants can be directly compared. Analysis of case control studies the odds ratio or is used in case control studies to estimate the strength of the association between exposure and outcome. Confounding is a distortion of the true relationship between exposure and disease by the in. A confounding variable is associated with the exposure and it affects the outcome, but.
214 964 934 467 507 535 1113 1209 1171 580 1505 864 476 1430 1438 743 436 786 653 1445 1170 535 1419 485 129 378 1139 173 1418 937 368 692 552 1158 1143 1187